Does everybody love Come From Away?

I hate to say it, but when I saw it several years ago, I disliked it pretty strongly. I actually saw it back to back with Dear Evan Hansen, and the combo had me concerned that I just didn't like musicals anymore, which thankfully turned out to be wrong.

Usually when I have a strong opinion on a show, I see a lot of people expressing the same opinion (e.g. DEH). But it seems like everyone on here just loves Come From Away. Am I wrong? Is there polarized opinion that I'm just not seeing?